Mason, Mariemont or Oakley? Choosing Where to Buy a New Home Near Cincinnati

Ashford new homes for sale in Mason, Mariemont and Oakley, Ohio

Shopping for new construction homes in Cincinnati? Ashford has homes for sale right now in three very different parts of the region. One is a five-bedroom house on a half acre in Mason. One is a townhome with an elevator in the historic village of Mariemont. One is a four-story home with a rooftop bar in Oakley.

They’re all around a million dollars. Beyond that, they don’t have much in common. The right choice depends less on the house and more on the life you want around it.

How Do the Three Homes Compare?

MasonMariemontOakley
Home5503 Cox-Smith RoadMiami Run #182921 Iron Oak Ave
Price$952,275$990,000 to $1,155,000$1,395,000
TypeTwo-story single-familyTownhome, 3 finished levelsFour-story single-family
Size3,992 sq ft (listed)about 2,532 sq ftabout 3,330 sq ft
Bedrooms52 or 34
Garage3-car, side entry2-car2-car
ElevatorNoYesYes
Outdoor spaceFlat half-acre yardRooftop terrace (select plans), small yardCovered rooftop deck with wet bar
SchoolsMason City SchoolsMariemont City SchoolsCincinnati Public Schools
CountyWarrenHamiltonHamilton
Tax abatementNone listed15 years listed (village)15-year LEED listed (city)

Prices are subject to change. Confirm current pricing and availability with the Ashford team.

Choose Mason If You Want Space

Mason is the classic suburban move. The Estates of Mason homesite at Cox-Smith Road is a flat half acre, which is hard to find in new Warren County construction. That’s room for a swing set, a garden or a future pool.

The Tacoma plan at 5503 Cox-Smith Road in Mason
The Tacoma plan at 5503 Cox-Smith Road, Mason

The house itself gives you five bedrooms, a finished lower level and a three-car garage. It’s the most square footage for the money of the three.

Mason City Schools earned five stars on the 2025-26 Ohio School Report Card. The district runs about 9,700 students through five buildings, so every family in the district shares the same middle and high school.

The trade-off is distance. Mason is about 22 miles from downtown Cincinnati. I-71 makes the drive easy, but you’ll drive to most things. Kings Island and the Cincinnati Open are close by, and local parks fill in the rest.

Choose Mariemont If You Want a Village

Mariemont is a planned 1920s village and a National Historic Landmark district. You can walk to Mariemont Square for dinner, a movie at the Mariemont Theatre or a summer concert at Dogwood Park.

Ashford townhomes at the Enclave of Mariemont
Ashford townhomes at the Enclave of Mariemont

The Enclave of Mariemont is one of the few places to buy new construction here. Miami Run #18 is a townhome, so you trade yard work for a rooftop terrace on select plans and an elevator that makes the three levels easy to live with for years.

The schools are a big draw. Mariemont City Schools earned five stars on the 2025-26 report card, with the third-highest overall score in Ohio, according to an AllK12 review of the results.

This is the best fit for downsizers who want to stay on the east side and families who care most about schools and walkability. It’s the smallest home of the three.

Choose Oakley If You Want the City

Oakley is a Cincinnati neighborhood with a busy square, restaurants, breweries and quick I-71 access at Edwards Road and Smith Road. Foundry Park sits on the former Kenner toy factory site and hosted Homearama in 2025.

The Phoenix at 2921 Iron Oak Avenue in Foundry Park, Oakley
The Phoenix at 2921 Iron Oak Avenue, Foundry Park

The Phoenix at 2921 Iron Oak builds up instead of out, with four levels, a private elevator and a rooftop deck with a wet bar and half bath. You get a big-house floor plan on a city lot.

Public schools are through Cincinnati Public Schools, which earned three stars on the 2025-26 report card, up from 2.5 stars, WLWT reported. Many Oakley families also look at magnet programs or nearby private schools such as St. Cecilia, Seven Hills and Summit Country Day.

This is the best fit for buyers who want to walk to dinner, entertain at home and live close to downtown. It’s also the highest price of the three.

How Do Property Taxes Differ?

Property taxes deserve a close look, because they make a real difference in your monthly cost.

  • Mason is in Warren County. No abatement is listed on this home.
  • Mariemont lists a 15-year abatement through the village. Confirm the terms with the Village of Mariemont.
  • Oakley lists a 15-year LEED abatement. Cincinnati changed its abatement program in 2023, so read our Cincinnati tax abatement guide and confirm the terms for the parcel with the Hamilton County Auditor.

An abatement covers some or all of the tax on the new home’s value, not the land. When you compare homes, ask for an estimated tax bill with and without the abatement.

A Quick Way to Decide

Ask yourself three questions:

  1. Do you want a yard or a rooftop? A yard points to Mason. A rooftop points to Mariemont or Oakley.
  2. How much do you want to drive? If you’d rather walk to dinner, Mariemont or Oakley.
  3. How many bedrooms do you need? Five points to Mason. Four to Oakley. Two or three to Mariemont.

Frequently Asked Questions

Where can I find new construction homes near Cincinnati?

Ashford has new homes for sale in Mason, Mariemont and Oakley, plus other areas. See every available home on our homes for sale page.

Which of these homes has the best schools?

Mason City Schools and Mariemont City Schools both earned five stars on the 2025-26 Ohio report cards. Mariemont’s overall score was third-highest in Ohio. Cincinnati Public Schools earned three stars. For the full regional list, see our guide to the best school districts near Cincinnati.

Do any of these new homes have elevators?

Yes. The Mariemont townhome and the Oakley home both include elevators.

Can Ashford build a custom home somewhere else?

Yes. We also build on your own land across Greater Cincinnati.

Tour All Three

Seeing these homes back to back is the fastest way to know which one feels right. Call the Ashford team at 513-445-1800 or contact us to set up showings.

Quotation mark
Do you like this article? Share it!

Related Posts

The Phoenix at 2921 Iron Oak Avenue: A Four-Story New Home in Oakley

Best School Districts Near Cincinnati: What the 2025-26 Ohio Report Cards Show

Miami Run #18: A New Elevator Townhome at the Enclave of Mariemont

The Phoenix at 2921 Iron Oak Avenue: A Four-Story New Home in Oakley

Best School Districts Near Cincinnati: What the 2025-26 Ohio Report Cards Show

Miami Run #18: A New Elevator Townhome at the Enclave of Mariemont